| 枫林在线论坛>>OK English [管理模式] [快速回复] [推荐给朋友] |
| [74037] 主题： Argument 115(第二篇^_^)(GRE) |
| 作者： donata |
标题：  Argument 115(第二篇^_^)(GRE)
|
|
| 昵称： donata-5iwj |
来自： 211.162.*.* 
|
|
| 经验值： 4528 | 发贴时间： 2003年07月19日 18:49:31 | |
| 等级： 对答如流 | 长度： 2037字 | |
|
Argument 115
The recommendation in this argument is that we should provide breakfasts for all students before each school day. Author mentions that eating breakfast before school plays a role in reducing student absenteeism and tardiness. An d author put forward a recent six-month study as example. This argument may seen to be somewhat convincing at first glance, but a close examination tell us the reason is implicit casual relation and false analogy. The primarily mistake is the implicit casual relation. Admittedly, children on the breakfast plan were less likely than other children to be absent from or late for school. However, it can’t be concluded that breakfast can redu ce the absenteeism. Other aspects such as nature of children, teachers’ ins truction are also significant. Another error is false analogy. Self-evidently, the theory is based on the s tudy. The age the study covered is five to twelve while the conclusion conce rns the elementary and secondary schools. It comes light that a five-year-ol d boy is before school age and secondary schools include the students who ag e from 12 to 14. Even if 100 students who are from elementary and secondary schools conquer the absenteeism by eating breakfast, not all the students ca n benefit from breakfast. Thirdly, the logical reasoning also has some defects. It can’t be seen “cl early ” that breakfast has anything to do with students’ tardiness. The au thor doesn’t state any reason for it. If breakfast is helpful to tardiness, we can raise the diet therapy to a higher level: not only physically subser vience, but mentally useful. In sum, there is no short cut of resolving the absenteeism. Only by teachers ’ conduction and students’ consciousness could students be kept from absen teeism. However, breakfast is necessary from the view of neutralist. 300 words,离500字差远了~~哎 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 春色三分，二分尘土，一分流水，细看来，不是扬花，点点是，离人泪…… 十年生死两茫茫，不思量，自难忘…… ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ |
|
|
========== * * * * * ==========
|
| 作者： chenqielton |
标题： RE:Argument 115(第二篇^_^)(GRE)
|
|
| 昵称： 晨 |
来自： 218.78.*.*
|
|
| 经验值： 294 | 发贴时间： 2003年07月19日 19:51:21 | |
| 等级： 白手起家 | 长度： 36字 | |
|
|
勤奋的好孩子，再给你点鼓励。。。：） |
|
|
========== * * * * * ==========
|
 Top
|
||